Book Read: Our Band Could Be Your Life
Author: Michael Azerrad
Pages: 522 (incl. index)
Music to Blog By: Grinderman, "Depth Charge Ethel"Method of Acquisition: During my honeymoon this past May, my husband and I made a stop in Kingston, Ontario. We both lived here for four years attending undergrad and met during our final year (I know. Awww! Retchhhh!) Like most former Kingstonians, we retain an eternal fondness for the Limestone City and our favorite haunts within.
Along with drinking pints of 50 at the Toucan, Brian's Record Option ranks as one of the most quintessential Kingstonian experiences. Basically, it's like a pack rat's basement vomited all over a tiny shop. You can navigate it yourself, stepping over treacherous piles of records, stickers, posters, cats and assorted detritus, or you can ask the impressively-bearded Brian, who somehow knows where everything is and is happy to jaw your ear off while he searches. (I was amused to discover that the store---and its owner---have been
immortalized on Youtube.
OK, so the point of this unnecessarily long and indulgent introduction is that we went there and asked Brian for good music books. He recommended
Our Band Could Be Your Life and
Last Night A DJ Saved My Life. It's hard to say no to Brian. He once encouraged me to buy the CD version of the Pump Up the Volume (!?) soundtrack because it featured Henry Rollins and Bad Brains doing a cover of "Kick Out the Jams." (Last I heard, my dad now uses it as a coaster, and Christian Slater's sly mug is now buried by a thin, omnipresent coating of cigarette ash.) But this time, that bearded pack rat steered me right.
A lot of books about bands and scenes and music history are dodgy. For every
Hammer of the Gods or
The Dirt you'll get a
This Must Be the Place (where author David Bowman succeeds completely in draining all vitality and wit from the story of the Talking Heads) or Ray Manzarek's blah-tastic book about the Doors (although I did enjoy one bit where he called Oliver Stone a fascist.)
When it comes to music books, dear readers, it would seem you're better off if you stick to a) Cultural critics and historians, who are generally pretty good at situating an artist's place in a particular historical context (and hopefully with a bit of literary flair) b) Nick Hornby, or c) Pure, unadulterated trash. Tell me about the record label tangles, the drugs, the babes, the overdoses, the near-fatal car accident, and the subsequent detox and relapse(s) and resulting incorporation of Ashtangi yoga, Kabbalah and psychotherapy into your Much Better, Arguably Less-Rockin' Life, with an afterword that features you sitting in your mansion with your Playboy Bunny-blonde wife, six absurd toy dogs, and plans for a VH1 series to hire a successor. Hire Neil Strauss to edit it all and you're set.
Our Band Could Be Your Life is a perfect mix of all these t
hings. It's a book that tells the following bands' stories, in about a chapter each: Mission of Burma, Butthole Surfers, The Minutemen, Sonic Youth, Big Black, Black Flag, Fugazi, Husker Du, Mudhoney, Minor Threat, Beat Happening, The Replacements and
Dinosaur Jr. And it's amazing how much he's able to pack into a single chapter. I thought I knew most of the important stuff about these bands, but every chapter held at least one revelation. (Literally every hardcore punk band in the book lists Creedence Clearwater Revival as a major influence! Greg Ginn is kind of a prick! Lydia Lunch once propositioned Steve Albini in a newspaper column!) The whole book is wonderfully researched and about as complete as any book on the subjective history of the American underground scene from the mid-to-late '80s could possibly be, ha-ha. He talks to all the surviving members from these bands as well as associates, old friends, parents, ex-girlfriends: You name it, he's spoken to them---and managed to make even the most tight-lipped players spill it. (The Big Black chapter, featuring Steve Albini's trademark I-don't-give-a-shit bluster, was hugely entertaining---and more than a little disturbing.)
Azerrad is also honest with us from the get-go, and I liked that. He admits as much in the introduction: He's not trying to do something comprehensive. (That's why, for example, there's no chapter on Bad Brains or D.O.A., even though many would argue they're equally as important in punk as Black Flag and Minor Threat, or why the Pixies have been left off the list.) He's just focused on a group of interesting bands who had a lot of crossover, supported one another through labels or just word of mouth, and who remain influential and relevant to this day. And without sounding gossipy or salacious, he presents the break-ups, the inter-band conflicts, the sordid road tales (the Butthole Surfers chapter actually made my hair stand on end) and the drugs and drink that, in some cases, led to a tragic downfall (like The Replacements! Well, shit!)
The best thing about reading
Our Band Could Be Your Life, though, is that it encourages you to re-listen (or discover) these bands and form your own personal soundtrack alongside the book. Azerrad's writing has an infectious, Lester Bangs-type quality that makes you want to buy these albums and listen to them, right now.
Here's an excerpt from his description of Husker Du's
Flip Your Wig:
"Except for two instrumentals tacked on to the end, every song sounds like a hit in some alternate world where the rivers run with an equal mixture of battery acid and honey."
I know, some may scoff. But for those of us who regularly struggle with music writing, trying to make it artful but not pretentious, trying to balance astuteness and wit with YOUR ACTUAL FEELINGS ABOUT THE SONG, that phrase is a fucking beautiful thing. I listened to the album (I had previously not heard any Husker Du except for the brilliant album everyone already knows/owns,
Zen Arcade) and he was right. It was amazing. So was reading about the sad and abrupt end of The Minutemen (NO SPOILERS!) while listening to
Double Nickels on the Dime. And after reading the Sonic Youth chapter and then listening to this year's release,
The Eternal, even though everyone and their mother has written a book or an article or made a movie featuring Sonic Youth, the chapter somehow helped me understand them a little better.
Okay. Most boring review ever. What I'm trying to say is that I enjoyed this book because music is an enormous part of my life. Quite a few of these bands had a huge formative effect on how I feel music should be--sound-wise, business-wise, appearance-wise, all of that. Azerrad's book is not only a useful time capsule for fanboys and girlies. It also hearkens back to a day when DIY was just starting and it wasn't yet feasible to go out on your own, manage your own tours, and press and mail your own records on your own label. But people like Fugazi and Minor Threat and Black Flag did it. The Butthole Surfers, in their early days, toured on their own terms. They were all dirt-poor, but they had control over their destinies in a way that some of their peers didn't. And that's kind of exciting. In a climate where music is more of a commodity than ever, Azerrad's book is an excellent primer on how to find your own way in one of the shittiest businesses of them all.